The lake house sold. The Roth conversion can wait for January.
You asked at our meeting whether to convert $200,000 to Roth this year. This year, that conversion lands on top of the $645,600 gain from the lake house and costs about $64,900 in federal tax and Medicare premiums. The same conversion in January costs about $46,000.
This year, the conversion stacks on top of the sale.
It pushes the gain into higher rates. The gain is taxed after your other income, so every dollar converted moves a dollar of gain up the ladder: from 0% to 15%, and from 15% to 20%. That adds $18,200.
It adds the 3.8% investment income tax. The conversion isn’t investment income, but it raises your income, so more of the gain is caught by the 3.8% tax: $6,500.
Medicare looks back two years. Your 2028 premiums are already at the top surcharge because of the sale; the conversion adds $1,200 more. In January, the conversion raises your 2029 premiums instead, by about $5,800, and it is still the cheaper year.
The dashed line is where gains start to be taxed at 20%. In 2026 the conversion pushes that much more of the gain past it.
The answer holds at any amount.
Move the slider to see what each timing adds to your federal tax and Medicare premiums, compared with not converting at all.
Stop at $196,000 in January.
Medicare surcharges step up at set income levels. A $200,000 conversion in 2027 puts your income at $278,000, just past the $274,000 step. Converting $196,000 keeps you below it and saves about $3,500 in 2029 premiums for $4,000 less converted. The $4,000 can go in 2028.
What happens between now and January.
- Before December 31No conversion this year. Set aside about $111,000 for the federal tax on the lake house sale.
- January 15, 2027Estimated tax payment for the sale, so there is no underpayment penalty in April.
- Early January 2027Proceeds move to your brokerage account. Convert $196,000 from your IRAs to your Roth IRAs.
- Fall 2027We look at the next conversion for 2028, before Medicare’s next look-back year closes.
The sale. Sold for $1,240,000, less 6% selling costs, against $520,000 of purchase price and improvements: a $645,600 long-term gain, closing in 2026. A second home gets no home-sale exclusion.
Your income. Mark’s $78,000 pension; you are both waiting to claim Social Security. Mark is 66 and Dana turns 65 in 2027.
Federal tax. 2026 brackets and capital gains thresholds for married filing jointly, used for 2027 too. Standard deduction with the additional amount for each spouse 65 or older and the senior deduction, which phases out as income rises. 3.8% tax on net investment income over $250,000.
Medicare. 2026 surcharge tiers for Parts B and D, for both of you, two years after the income year. Costs are what each choice adds compared with not converting; growth on the Roth is the same in every case and is left out.
Confidential, prepared for Dana and Mark Brennan. Prepared November 2026. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions above and on 2026 tax and Medicare tables; 2027 tables will differ slightly. This is not tax advice; please review with your CPA before converting.
This sample interaction is a derivative of real advisor work in Helmsted, fully de-identified: a hypothetical composite with fictitious names. Dana and Mark Brennan and Caldermont Private Wealth are fictitious.
Built with Helmsted.