The question came up in the meeting. The answer went out that week.
Dana and Mark Brennan came in for their fall review. Their advisor set his laptop on the table, asked if they were comfortable being recorded, and pressed Start recording. Halfway through, Dana said: “We accepted the offer on the lake house. Should we still do the $200,000 Roth conversion this year?” By the time the Brennans reached the parking lot, the meeting notes were written, and “Send the Roth conversion projection by Friday” was waiting under Suggested next.
1. “Start.” The advisor pressed Start on the suggestion. Helmsted opened a session with Dana’s question from the transcript, the sale terms from the closing papers, Mark’s pension and the IRA balances. A $1,240,000 sale, less selling costs, against $520,000 of purchase price and improvements: a $645,600 gain, and as a second home, none of it excluded.
2. “What does $200,000 cost them this year, in January, or split across both?” This year, about $64,900 in federal tax and Medicare premiums. The conversion lands on top of the gain, pushing more of it into higher capital gains rates and the 3.8% investment income tax. In January, with no gain underneath it, about $46,000. Split, $50,200.
3. “Is there a better number for January?” Medicare surcharges step up at set income levels, and $200,000 puts their 2027 income at $278,000, just past the $274,000 step. Converting $196,000 keeps them under it and saves about $3,500 in 2029 premiums.
4. “Put it in a report they can play with, and draft the email.” A report in the firm’s brand with one control, the amount to convert, and a timeline: no conversion before December 31, an estimated tax payment for the sale on January 15, and the conversion in early January. The email to the Brennans and their CPA went out Thursday, a day early.
The advisor catches the question
Year-end Roth conversions are routine. The year a client sells something isn’t, and the question usually comes up in passing, in a meeting about something else. The advisor’s job is to catch it, show what it really costs, tax and Medicare together, and answer before the year closes. Helmsted keeps the question from getting lost between the meeting and the follow-up.
Getting creative with materials with Helmsted
Answer the question in their words. The report opens with what Dana asked, so the answer reads as a reply, not a lecture. Show dollars, not rates. One total for each choice, with Medicare premiums included, is easier to decide on than a list of brackets. Look for the step. Converting $4,000 less keeps them under a Medicare step and saves $3,500, the kind of detail that is easy to miss by hand. Give them dates. Three dates between now and January, so the plan doesn’t slip into next year by accident.
One thing makes all of it work: context. Helmsted needs the closing statement, the original purchase price and improvements, current income, IRA balances, and both spouses’ ages and Medicare enrollment.
New this week: record in-person meetings with Helmsted.
